Fay Cafe
Inside Fay Cafe
Fay Cafe in Sedona offers more than just your average coffee stop—it’s a spot where the craft of coffee and a thoughtfully curated atmosphere come together in a quiet stretch of W State Route 89A. This cafe specializes in pour-over coffee using local Sedona-roasted FreeForm blends, a feature that draws those who appreciate watching the meticulous brewing process as much as savoring the final cup. The option to choose between two blends and sizes adds a personal touch that coffee enthusiasts tend to appreciate.
The vibe at Fay Cafe leans toward relaxed and cozy, with a stylish interior tastefully accented by local art and ceramics, which customers often browse while settling in. It’s the kind of place where you could easily spend an afternoon catching up on work, diving into a book, or just enjoying some downtime away from busier parts of town. The soundtrack, occasionally lined with owner-spun records, adds a low-key soundtrack that complements rather than competes with conversation or concentration.
The menu is unpretentious but well thought out—beyond coffee, you'll find a selection of organic, vegan, and gluten-free snack bars made locally, adding a wholesome energy boost for those lingering longer. Flavored syrup options provide subtle sweetness or a little flavor twist, such as organic vanilla or cardamom, allowing drinks to be customized without overwhelming the base coffee quality.
Locals and visitors alike find Fay Cafe to be a welcoming stop, partly due to the personable service from the owner and staff, who engage with guests in a way that feels genuine and earnest. This makes the cafe feel more like a community hub than just a quick caffeine fix. Morning or early afternoon tends to be the best time to visit for those wanting to catch the calm before the mid-day rush or to settle in for a slow-paced afternoon.
Overall, Fay Cafe suits those who appreciate hand-crafted coffee experiences paired with a quiet, artful setting. Whether you’re a traveler winding down from Sedona’s outdoor adventures or a local looking for a friendly spot to work or relax, this cafe offers a thoughtfully layered experience that merges great coffee with a welcoming environment.
Highlights & Local Essentials
Find It on the Map
What Locals & Travelers Say
56 Reviews
06 Jan 2026
28 Dec 2025
22 Dec 2025
14 Dec 2025
14 Dec 2025
09 Dec 2025
17 Oct 2025
22 Sep 2025
More Local Spots to Explore
Dab Hand by Hiritsu Coffee Roastery
Broadway fried chicken and pizza
Restoran Good Taste Jalil Link
The Perch
Café Kucheneck
Join the Fay Cafe Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.